| DOB | Players | Clubs | Nationality | SD | A(D) | More |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10-Feb-1974 |  Scott McGleish | Bristol Rovers | England | 11-Feb-2012 | 38(0) | |
| 11-Dec-1975 |  Stewart Drummond | Morecambe | England | 31-Mar-2012 | 36(110) | |
| 14-Oct-1975 | Michael Duberry | Oxford United | England | 21-Jan-2012 | 36(97) | |
| 14-Feb-1976 |  Darren Purse | Plymouth Argyle | England | 28-Apr-2012 | 36(74) | |
| 19-Jun-1976 | Bryan Hughes | Accrington Stanley | England | 21-Apr-2012 | 35(305) | |
| 31-Aug-1976 |  Ashley Westwood | Northampton Town | England | 13-Aug-2011 | 34(347) | |
| 17-Nov-1976 | Paul McLaren | Oxford United | England | 24-Sep-2011 | 34(310) | |
| 12-Jul-1977 |  Neil Harris | Southend United | England | 05-May-2012 | 34(296) | |
| 15-Oct-1976 | Jamie Stuart | AFC Wimbledon | England | 06-Aug-2011 | 34(295) | |
| 17-Aug-1977 | Paul Wotton | Plymouth Argyle | England | 17-Mar-2012 | 34(211) | |
| 12-Apr-1977 | Jason Price | Barnet | Wales | 22-Oct-2011 | 34(192) | |
| 09-Oct-1977 |  Mark Arber | Dagenham & Redbridge | South Africa | 14-Feb-2012 | 34(126) | |
| 23-Dec-1977 | Kevin McIntyre | Accrington Stanley | England | 28-Apr-2012 | 34(126) | |
| 29-Oct-1978 |  Steve Elliott | Cheltenham Town | England | 18-Feb-2012 | 33(110) | |
| 24-Jan-1979 |  Danny Bulman | Crawley Town | England | 20-Mar-2012 | 33(54) | |
| 23-Feb-1979 | Kevin Ellison | Morecambe | England | 17-Mar-2012 | 33(22) | |
| 19-Sep-1978 | Sean Hessey | Accrington Stanley | England | 01-Oct-2011 | 33(11) | |
| 06-Mar-1979 | Claude Davis | Crawley Town | Jamaica | 10-Mar-2012 | 33(3) | |
| 23-Nov-1978 | Ben Smith | Crawley Town | England | 03-Sep-2011 | 32(284) | |
| 15-Aug-1979 | Gary Alexander | Crawley Town | England | 14-Apr-2012 | 32(242) | |
| 15-Feb-1979 | Josh Low | Cheltenham Town | England | 14-Oct-2011 | 32(241) | |
| 09-Jan-1979 |  Guy Branston | Bradford City | England | 27-Aug-2011 | 32(230) | |
| 25-Sep-1979 | Jim Paterson | Bristol Rovers | Scotland | 14-Apr-2012 | 32(202) | |
| 12-Oct-1979 |  Paul Benson | Swindon Town | England | 28-Apr-2012 | 32(198) | |
| 14-Oct-1979 | Clarke Carlisle | Northampton Town | England | 14-Apr-2012 | 32(182) | |
| 01-Aug-1979 | Phillip Jevons | Morecambe | England | 21-Jan-2012 | 32(171) | |
| 22-Apr-1980 |  Delroy Facey | Hereford United | Grenada | 05-May-2012 | 32(12) | |
| 23-Nov-1979 | Nick Fenton | Morecambe | England | 05-Nov-2011 | 31(347) | |
| 17-Sep-1980 | Oliver Risser | Swindon Town | Namibia | 03-Apr-2012 | 31(199) | |
| 10-Apr-1980 |  Danny Schofield | Rotherham United | England | 14-Oct-2011 | 31(186) |
SD = Scored Date ,
DOB = Date Of Birth ,
A(D) = Age(Days) .