| MD | Players | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 31-Dec-1994 | Gordon Strachan | Scotland | 09-Feb-1957 | 37(325) |
| 16-Jan-1993 | Mervyn Day | England | 26-Jun-1955 | 37(205) |
| 20-Jan-1996 | Lee Chapman | England | 05-Dec-1959 | 36(46) |
| 23-May-2021 | Pablo Hernandez | Spain | 11-Apr-1985 | 36(42) |
| 07-May-1994 | David O'Leary | England | 02-May-1958 | 36(5) |
| 11-May-2002 | Nigel Martyn | England | 11-Aug-1966 | 35(274) |
| 11-May-1997 | Ian Rush | Wales | 20-Oct-1961 | 35(204) |
| 05-May-1996 | John Lukic | England | 11-Dec-1960 | 35(146) |
| 07-Jan-2004 | David Batty | England | 02-Dec-1968 | 35(36) |
| 15-May-2004 | Lucas Radebe | South Africa | 12-Apr-1969 | 35(34) |
| 19-Oct-1996 | Mark Hateley | England | 07-Nov-1961 | 34(347) |
| 23-May-2021 | Kiko Casilla | Spain | 02-Oct-1986 | 34(234) |
| 05-May-1996 | Nigel Worthington | Northern Ireland | 04-Nov-1961 | 34(183) |
| 12-Apr-1999 | Gunnar Halle | Norway | 11-Aug-1965 | 33(244) |
| 28-Dec-1992 | Imre Varadi | England | 08-Jul-1959 | 33(174) |
| 19-Oct-1996 | Richard Jobson | England | 09-May-1963 | 33(164) |
| 28-May-2023 | Joel Robles | Spain | 17-Jun-1990 | 32(345) |
| 15-May-2004 | Jason Wilcox | England | 15-Jul-1971 | 32(305) |
| 23-May-2021 | Gaetano Berardi | Switzerland | 21-Aug-1988 | 32(275) |
| 04-Jan-2023 | Mateusz Klich | Poland | 13-Jun-1990 | 32(205) |
| 28-May-2023 | Rodrigo Moreno | Spain | 06-Mar-1991 | 32(83) |
| 28-May-2023 | Luke Ayling | England | 25-Aug-1991 | 31(276) |
| 28-May-2023 | Liam Cooper | Scotland | 30-Aug-1991 | 31(271) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).