| MD | Players | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30-Dec-2006 | Teddy Sheringham | England | 02-Apr-1966 | 40(272) |
| 11-Feb-2015 | Jussi Jaaskelainen | Finland | 19-Apr-1975 | 39(299) |
| 11-May-1997 | Les Sealey | England | 29-Sep-1957 | 39(225) |
| 02-Feb-2003 | Nigel Winterburn | England | 11-Dec-1963 | 39(54) |
| 19-May-2001 | Stuart Pearce | England | 24-Apr-1962 | 39(26) |
| 14-Apr-2024 | Lukasz Fabianski | Poland | 18-Apr-1985 | 38(362) |
| 05-May-1996 | Alvin Martin | England | 29-Jul-1958 | 37(281) |
| 07-May-2006 | Shaka Hislop | Trinidad and Tobago | 22-Feb-1969 | 37(74) |
| 05-May-2018 | Patrice Evra | France | 15-May-1981 | 36(355) |
| 11-May-2003 | Les Ferdinand | England | 18-Dec-1966 | 36(144) |
| 19-Jan-2003 | John Moncur | England | 22-Sep-1966 | 36(119) |
| 06-Dec-1997 | Lukek Miklosko | Czech Republic | 09-Dec-1961 | 35(363) |
| 02-Mar-2024 | Angelo Ogbonna | Italy | 23-May-1988 | 35(284) |
| 08-May-1999 | Ian Wright | England | 03-Nov-1963 | 35(187) |
| 10-May-1998 | Bernard Lama | France | 07-Apr-1963 | 35(34) |
| 22-May-2022 | Mark Noble | England | 08-May-1987 | 35(15) |
| 22-Jan-2020 | Pablo Zabaleta | Argentina | 16-Jan-1985 | 35(6) |
| 01-Nov-1994 | Lee Chapman | England | 05-Dec-1959 | 34(332) |
| 11-May-2003 | Paolo Di Canio | Italy | 09-Jul-1968 | 34(306) |
| 13-May-2018 | James Collins | Wales | 23-Aug-1983 | 34(264) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).