| MD | Players | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 06-May-2018 | Aaron Wilbraham | England | 21-Oct-1979 | 38(198) |
| 07-May-2016 | Emile Heskey | England | 11-Jan-1978 | 38(117) |
| 02-May-2015 | Eidur Gudjohnsen | Iceland | 15-Sep-1978 | 36(229) |
| 09-Mar-2019 | Lloyd Dyer | England | 13-Sep-1982 | 36(177) |
| 05-May-2019 | Gary O'Neil | England | 18-May-1983 | 35(353) |
| 09-Mar-2013 | Kevin Davies | England | 26-Mar-1977 | 35(349) |
| 06-May-2018 | Karl Henry | England | 26-Nov-1982 | 35(162) |
| 22-Apr-2019 | Clayton Donaldson | Jamaica | 07-Feb-1984 | 35(75) |
| 19-Mar-2016 | Paul Rachubka | England | 21-May-1981 | 34(303) |
| 23-Jan-2016 | Shola Ameobi | Nigeria | 21-Oct-1981 | 34(94) |
| 03-May-2014 | Zatyiah Knight | England | 02-May-1980 | 34(1) |
| 26-Dec-2012 | Martin Petrov | Bulgaria | 15-Jan-1979 | 33(346) |
| 07-May-2016 | Neil Danns | Guyana | 23-Nov-1982 | 33(166) |
| 07-May-2016 | Stephen Dobbie | Scotland | 05-Dec-1982 | 33(154) |
| 20-Apr-2013 | Danny Butterfield | England | 21-Nov-1979 | 33(151) |
| 06-May-2018 | Darren Pratley | England | 22-Apr-1985 | 33(14) |
| 03-Aug-2013 | Keith Andrews | Republic of Ireland | 18-Sep-1980 | 32(319) |
| 05-May-2019 | Andrew Taylor | England | 01-Aug-1986 | 32(277) |
| 03-Mar-2015 | Kevin McNaughton | Scotland | 28-Aug-1982 | 32(187) |
| 06-May-2018 | Filipe Morais | Portugal | 21-Nov-1985 | 32(166) |
| 22-Apr-2019 | Ben Alnwick | England | 01-Jan-1987 | 32(111) |
| 19-Apr-2019 | David Wheater | England | 14-Feb-1987 | 32(64) |
| 18-Apr-2015 | Patrick McCarthy | Republic of Ireland | 31-May-1983 | 31(323) |
| 11-Aug-2018 | Adam Le Fondre | England | 02-Dec-1986 | 31(252) |
| 09-Apr-2019 | Marc Wilson | Republic of Ireland | 17-Aug-1987 | 31(236) |
| 04-May-2013 | Sam Ricketts | Wales | 11-Oct-1981 | 31(205) |
| 05-May-2019 | Craig Noone | England | 17-Nov-1987 | 31(170) |
| 21-Feb-2015 | Andy Lonergan | England | 19-Oct-1983 | 31(125) |
| 05-May-2019 | Jonathan Grounds | England | 02-Feb-1988 | 31(93) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).