| MD | Players | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 08-Apr-2017 | Wes Brown | England | 13-Oct-1979 | 37(178) |
| 05-Mar-2024 | Kyle McFadzean | England | 22-Feb-1987 | 37(12) |
| 27-Apr-2013 | Nuno Gomes | Portugal | 05-Jul-1976 | 36(296) |
| 08-May-2021 | Stewart Downing | England | 22-Jul-1984 | 36(290) |
| 04-Feb-2017 | Gordon Greer | Scotland | 14-Dec-1980 | 36(52) |
| 01-Apr-2013 | Danny Murphy | England | 18-Mar-1977 | 36(14) |
| 02-May-2015 | David Dunn | England | 27-Dec-1979 | 35(127) |
| 22-Jul-2020 | Danny Graham | England | 12-Aug-1985 | 34(345) |
| 17-Sep-2014 | Paul Robinson | England | 15-Oct-1979 | 34(338) |
| 18-Apr-2022 | Bradley Johnson | England | 24-Aug-1987 | 34(238) |
| 30-Jun-2020 | Charlie Mulgrew | Scotland | 06-Mar-1986 | 34(117) |
| 05-May-2019 | Craig Conway | Scotland | 02-May-1985 | 34(3) |
| 12-Jan-2016 | Lee Williamson | Jamaica | 07-Jun-1982 | 33(219) |
| 02-May-2015 | Bradley Orr | England | 01-Nov-1982 | 32(182) |
| 08-May-2023 | Daniel Ayala | Spain | 07-Nov-1990 | 32(182) |
| 24-Apr-2021 | Elliott Bennett | England | 18-Dec-1988 | 32(127) |
| 07-May-2016 | Matthew Kilgallon | England | 08-Jan-1984 | 32(120) |
| 07-May-2017 | Elliott Ward | England | 19-Jan-1985 | 32(108) |
| 11-Jan-2014 | DJ Campbell | England | 12-Nov-1981 | 32(60) |
| 22-Nov-2014 | Luke Varney | England | 28-Sep-1982 | 32(55) |
| 08-Apr-2014 | Dickson Etuhu | Nigeria | 08-Jun-1982 | 31(305) |
| 04-May-2013 | Morten Gamst Pedersen | Norway | 08-Sep-1981 | 31(239) |
| 20-Apr-2021 | Barry Douglas | Scotland | 04-Sep-1989 | 31(228) |
| 20-Apr-2013 | Gael Givet | France | 09-Oct-1981 | 31(194) |
| 19-Apr-2016 | Chris Brown | England | 11-Dec-1984 | 31(130) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).