| MD | Players | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 04-Jul-1994 | Fernando Clavijo | United States | 23-Jan-1956 | 38(163) |
| 25-Jun-1998 | Tom Dooley | United States | 21-May-1961 | 37(35) |
| 27-May-1934 | Tom Florie | United States | 06-Sep-1897 | 36(262) |
| 22-Jun-2006 | Kasey Keller | United States | 19-Nov-1969 | 36(215) |
| 01-Jul-2014 | Tim Howard | United States | 06-Mar-1979 | 35(118) |
| 03-Dec-2022 | Tim Ream | United States | 05-Oct-1987 | 35(60) |
| 25-Jun-1998 | Preki Radosavljevic | United States | 24-Jun-1963 | 35(2) |
| 14-Jun-2002 | Jeff Agoos | United States | 05-Feb-1968 | 34(130) |
| 21-Jun-1998 | Roy Wegerle | United States | 19-Mar-1964 | 34(94) |
| 22-Jun-2006 | Brian McBride | United States | 19-Jun-1972 | 34(3) |
| 21-Jun-2002 | Earnie Stewart | United States | 28-Mar-1969 | 33(85) |
| 27-May-1934 | George Moorhouse | United States | 04-May-1901 | 33(23) |
| 17-Jun-2002 | Carlos Llamosa | United States | 30-Jun-1969 | 32(352) |
| 22-Jun-2006 | Claudio Reyna | United States | 20-Jul-1973 | 32(337) |
| 01-Jul-2014 | Jermaine Jones | United States | 03-Nov-1981 | 32(240) |
| 26-Jun-2014 | Brad Davis | United States | 08-Nov-1981 | 32(230) |
| 26-Jul-1930 | Jimmy Douglas | United States | 12-Jan-1898 | 32(194) |
| 17-Jun-2006 | Eddie Pope | United States | 24-Dec-1973 | 32(175) |
| 26-Jun-2014 | Kyle Beckerman | United States | 23-Apr-1982 | 32(64) |
| 01-Jul-2014 | DaMarcus Beasley | United States | 24-May-1982 | 32(38) |
| 22-Jun-2006 | Eddie Lewis | United States | 17-May-1974 | 32(36) |
| 21-Jun-2002 | Cobi Jones | United States | 16-Jun-1970 | 32(5) |
| 21-Jun-1998 | Tab Ramos | United States | 21-Sep-1966 | 31(273) |
| 26-Jun-2010 | Steve Cherundolo | United States | 19-Feb-1979 | 31(128) |
| 01-Jul-2014 | Clint Dempsey | United States | 09-Mar-1983 | 31(115) |
| 14-Jun-2002 | Joe-Max Moore | United States | 23-Feb-1971 | 31(112) |
| 26-Jul-1930 | Bart McGhee | United States | 30-Apr-1899 | 31(86) |
| 27-May-1934 | Julius Hjulian | United States | 15-Mar-1903 | 31(73) |
| 21-Jun-2002 | Brad Friedel | United States | 18-May-1971 | 31(35) |
| 26-Jun-2010 | Carlos Bocanegra | United States | 25-May-1979 | 31(33) |
| 21-Jun-2002 | Tony Sanneh | United States | 01-Jun-1971 | 31(20) |
| 18-Jun-1994 | Cle Kooiman | United States | 03-Jul-1963 | 30(351) |
| 01-Jul-2014 | Chris Wondolowski | United States | 28-Jul-1983 | 30(339) |
| 25-Jun-1998 | Marcelo Balboa | United States | 08-Aug-1967 | 30(322) |
| 04-Jul-1994 | Hugo Perez | United States | 08-Nov-1963 | 30(239) |
| 25-Jun-1950 | Adam Wolanin | United States | 13-Nov-1919 | 30(225) |
| 26-Jun-2010 | Jay DeMerit | United States | 04-Dec-1979 | 30(205) |
| 26-Jul-1930 | Andy Auld | United States | 26-Jan-1900 | 30(181) |
| 27-May-1934 | Bill McLean | United States | 27-Jan-1904 | 30(121) |
| 04-Jul-1994 | Paul Caligiuri | United States | 09-Mar-1964 | 30(117) |
| 27-May-1934 | Werner Nilsen | United States | 24-Feb-1904 | 30(93) |
| 02-Jul-1950 | John Souza | United States | 12-Jul-1920 | 29(355) |
| 02-Jul-1950 | Charlie Colombo | United States | 20-Jul-1920 | 29(347) |
| 17-Jun-2006 | Pablo Mastroeni | United States | 29-Aug-1976 | 29(292) |
| 02-Jul-1950 | Joe Maca | United States | 28-Sep-1920 | 29(277) |
| 25-Jun-1998 | David Regis | United States | 02-Dec-1968 | 29(205) |
| 03-Dec-2022 | Walker Zimmerman | United States | 19-May-1993 | 29(198) |
| 03-Dec-2022 | DeAndre Yedlin | United States | 09-Jul-1993 | 29(147) |
| 22-Jun-2006 | Jimmy Conrad | United States | 12-Feb-1977 | 29(130) |
| 12-Jun-2006 | Josh Wolff | United States | 25-Feb-1977 | 29(107) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).