| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13-Jan-2004 |  Kevin Poole | Bolton Wanderers | England | 21-Jul-1963 | 40(176) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  David Seaman | Manchester City | England | 19-Sep-1963 | 40(106) |
| 07-Mar-2004 |  Stuart McCall | Sheffield United | Scotland | 10-Jun-1964 | 39(271) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Denis Irwin | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Republic of Ireland | 31-Oct-1965 | 38(64) |
| 24-Feb-2004 |  Robert Lee | West Ham United | England | 01-Feb-1966 | 38(23) |
| 06-Mar-2004 |  Teddy Sheringham | Portsmouth | England | 02-Apr-1966 | 37(339) |
| 25-Jan-2004 |  Nigel Martyn | Everton | England | 11-Aug-1966 | 37(167) |
| 04-Jan-2004 |  Martin Keown | Arsenal | England | 24-Jul-1966 | 37(164) |
| 19-May-2004 |  Dennis Wise | Millwall | England | 16-Dec-1966 | 37(155) |
| 14-Jan-2004 |  Les Ferdinand | Leicester City | England | 18-Dec-1966 | 37(27) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Paul Cook | Accrington Stanley | England | 22-Feb-1967 | 36(315) |
| 25-Jan-2004 | Paul Ince | Wolverhampton Wanderers | England | 21-Oct-1967 | 36(96) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Gustavo Poyet | Tottenham Hotspur | Uruguay | 15-Nov-1967 | 36(49) |
| 15-Feb-2004 | Mike Whitlow | Sheffield United | England | 13-Jan-1968 | 36(33) |
| 24-Feb-2004 | Brian Deane | West Ham United | England | 07-Feb-1968 | 36(17) |
| 13-Jan-2004 | John Williams | Kidderminster Harriers | England | 11-May-1968 | 35(247) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Craig Short | Blackburn Rovers | England | 25-Jun-1968 | 35(192) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Iwan Roberts | Norwich City | Wales | 26-Jun-1968 | 35(191) |
| 14-Feb-2004 |  Roger Freestone | Swansea City | Wales | 19-Aug-1968 | 35(179) |
| 25-Jan-2004 | Oleg Luzhniy | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Ukraine | 05-Aug-1968 | 35(173) |
| 15-Feb-2004 | Wayne Allison | Sheffield United | England | 16-Oct-1968 | 35(122) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Marcel Desailly | Chelsea | France | 07-Sep-1968 | 35(118) |
| 04-Jan-2004 |  David Batty | Leeds United | England | 02-Dec-1968 | 35(33) |
| 06-Mar-2004 | Shaka Hislop | Portsmouth | Trinidad and Tobago | 22-Feb-1969 | 35(13) |
| 03-Apr-2004 | Dennis Bergkamp | Arsenal | Netherlands | 18-May-1969 | 34(321) |
| 14-Jan-2004 | Billy McKinlay | Leicester City | Scotland | 22-Apr-1969 | 34(267) |
| 04-Jan-2004 |  Ronny Johnsen | Aston Villa | Norway | 10-Jun-1969 | 34(208) |
| 03-Apr-2004 | Jens Lehmann | Arsenal | Germany | 10-Nov-1969 | 34(145) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Scott Fitzgerald | Colchester United | England | 13-Aug-1969 | 34(143) |
| 24-Jan-2004 |  Gary Speed | Newcastle United | Wales | 08-Sep-1969 | 34(138) |
| 14-Feb-2004 | Michael Tarnat | Manchester City | Germany | 27-Oct-1969 | 34(110) |
| 03-Jan-2004 | Alex Rae | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Scotland | 30-Sep-1969 | 34(95) |
| 25-Jan-2004 | Kasey Keller | Tottenham Hotspur | United States | 19-Nov-1969 | 34(67) |
| 03-Jan-2004 | Craig Hignett | Leicester City | England | 12-Jan-1970 | 33(356) |
| 15-Feb-2004 | Neil Sullivan | Chelsea | Scotland | 24-Feb-1970 | 33(356) |
| 13-Jan-2004 | Per Frandsen | Bolton Wanderers | Denmark | 06-Feb-1970 | 33(341) |
| 03-Jan-2004 | Kevin Campbell | Everton | England | 04-Feb-1970 | 33(333) |
| 06-Mar-2004 | Arjan de Zeeuw | Portsmouth | Netherlands | 16-Apr-1970 | 33(325) |
| 25-Jan-2004 | Paul Bosvelt | Manchester City | Netherlands | 26-Mar-1970 | 33(305) |
| 07-Mar-2004 |  Shane Nicholson | Tranmere Rovers | Northern Ireland | 03-Jun-1970 | 33(278) |
| 16-Mar-2004 | Sean Connelly | Tranmere Rovers | England | 26-Jun-1970 | 33(264) |
| 14-Feb-2004 |  David May | Burnley | England | 24-Jun-1970 | 33(235) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Tony Vidmar | Cardiff City | Australia | 04-Jul-1970 | 33(183) |
| 25-Feb-2004 |  Jeff Kenna | Birmingham City | Republic of Ireland | 27-Aug-1970 | 33(182) |
| 24-Jan-2004 | Alan Shearer | Newcastle United | England | 13-Aug-1970 | 33(164) |
| 03-Jan-2004 | Kerimoglu Tugay | Blackburn Rovers | Turkey | 24-Aug-1970 | 33(132) |
| 06-Mar-2004 |  Edwin van der Sar | Fulham | Netherlands | 29-Oct-1970 | 33(129) |
| 04-Apr-2004 |  Phil Babb | Sunderland | Republic of Ireland | 30-Nov-1970 | 33(126) |
| 03-Jan-2004 |  Gareth Southgate | Middlesbrough | England | 03-Sep-1970 | 33(122) |
| 14-Jan-2004 |  Marcus Gayle | Watford | Jamaica | 27-Sep-1970 | 33(109) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).