| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15-May-2012 |  Ian Bennett | Huddersfield Town | England | 10-Oct-1971 | 40(218) |
| 14-May-2012 |  Chris Day | Stevenage | England | 28-Jul-1975 | 36(291) |
| 26-May-2012 |  Richard Cresswell | Sheffield United | England | 20-Sep-1977 | 34(249) |
| 26-May-2012 | Alan Lee | Huddersfield Town | Republic of Ireland | 21-Aug-1978 | 33(279) |
| 26-May-2012 | Damien Johnson | Huddersfield Town | Northern Ireland | 18-Nov-1978 | 33(190) |
| 26-May-2012 | Tommy Miller | Huddersfield Town | Scotland | 08-Jan-1979 | 33(139) |
| 26-May-2012 | Steve Simonsen | Sheffield United | England | 03-Apr-1979 | 33(54) |
| 14-May-2012 | Patrick Agyemang | Stevenage | Ghana | 29-Sep-1980 | 31(228) |
| 15-May-2012 |  Alan Smith | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 28-Oct-1980 | 31(199) |
| 15-May-2012 | Luke Chadwick | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 18-Nov-1980 | 31(178) |
| 15-May-2012 | Charlie MacDonald | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 13-Feb-1981 | 31(91) |
| 26-May-2012 | Matt Hill | Sheffield United | England | 26-Mar-1981 | 31(62) |
| 26-May-2012 | Michael Doyle | Sheffield United | Republic of Ireland | 08-Jul-1981 | 30(323) |
| 26-May-2012 | Nick Montgomery | Sheffield United | England | 28-Oct-1981 | 30(211) |
| 26-May-2012 | Peter Clarke | Huddersfield Town | England | 03-Jan-1982 | 30(144) |
| 26-May-2012 | Lee Williamson | Sheffield United | Jamaica | 07-Jun-1982 | 29(354) |
| 14-May-2012 | Jon Ashton | Stevenage | England | 04-Oct-1982 | 29(223) |
| 11-May-2012 | Johannes Ertl | Sheffield United | Austria | 13-Nov-1982 | 29(180) |
| 15-May-2012 | Jabo Ibehre | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 28-Jan-1983 | 29(108) |
| 26-May-2012 | Neill Collins | Sheffield United | Scotland | 02-Sep-1983 | 28(267) |
| 14-May-2012 | Mark Roberts | Stevenage | England | 16-Oct-1983 | 28(211) |
| 26-May-2012 | Chris Porter | Sheffield United | England | 12-Dec-1983 | 28(166) |
| 14-May-2012 | Chris Beardsley | Stevenage | England | 28-Feb-1984 | 28(76) |
| 15-May-2012 | Dean Lewington | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 18-May-1984 | 27(362) |
| 15-May-2012 | Darren Potter | Milton Keynes Dons | Republic of Ireland | 21-Dec-1984 | 27(145) |
| 15-May-2012 | Gary MacKenzie | Milton Keynes Dons | Scotland | 15-Oct-1985 | 26(213) |
| 14-May-2012 | Craig Reid | Stevenage | England | 17-Dec-1985 | 26(149) |
| 15-May-2012 | David Martin | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 22-Jan-1986 | 26(114) |
| 15-May-2012 | Anton Robinson | Huddersfield Town | England | 17-Feb-1986 | 26(88) |
| 26-May-2012 | Andy Taylor | Sheffield United | England | 14-Mar-1986 | 26(74) |
| 26-May-2012 | Stephen Quinn | Sheffield United | Republic of Ireland | 01-Apr-1986 | 26(56) |
| 14-May-2012 | John Mousinho | Stevenage | England | 30-Apr-1986 | 26(15) |
| 15-May-2012 | Dean Bowditch | Milton Keynes Dons | England | 15-Jun-1986 | 25(335) |
| 14-May-2012 | Joel Byrom | Stevenage | England | 14-Sep-1986 | 25(243) |
| 15-May-2012 | Shaun Williams | Milton Keynes Dons | Republic of Ireland | 19-Oct-1986 | 25(209) |
| 26-May-2012 | Calum Woods | Huddersfield Town | England | 05-Feb-1987 | 25(111) |
| 14-May-2012 | Lawrie Wilson | Stevenage | England | 11-Sep-1987 | 24(246) |
| 15-May-2012 | Tom Clarke | Huddersfield Town | England | 21-Dec-1987 | 24(146) |
| 14-May-2012 | Robin Shroot | Stevenage | England | 26-Mar-1988 | 24(49) |
| 14-May-2012 | Scott Laird | Stevenage | England | 15-May-1988 | 23(364) |
| 14-May-2012 | Michael Bostwick | Stevenage | England | 17-May-1988 | 23(362) |
| 11-May-2012 | Jennison Myrie-Williams | Stevenage | England | 17-May-1988 | 23(359) |
| 15-May-2012 | Stephen Gleeson | Milton Keynes Dons | Republic of Ireland | 03-Aug-1988 | 23(285) |
| 15-May-2012 | Jay O'Shea | Milton Keynes Dons | Republic of Ireland | 10-Aug-1988 | 23(278) |
| 26-May-2012 | Ryan Flynn | Sheffield United | Scotland | 04-Sep-1988 | 23(264) |
| 26-May-2012 | Lee Novak | Huddersfield Town | England | 28-Sep-1988 | 23(240) |
| 26-May-2012 | Scott Arfield | Huddersfield Town | Canada | 01-Nov-1988 | 23(206) |
| 14-May-2012 | Kevin McDonald | Sheffield United | Scotland | 04-Nov-1988 | 23(191) |
| 26-May-2012 | Matthew Lowton | Sheffield United | England | 09-Jun-1989 | 22(352) |
| 26-May-2012 | Kallum Higginbotham | Huddersfield Town | England | 15-Jun-1989 | 22(346) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).