| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16-May-2012 |  Neil Harris | Southend United | England | 12-Jul-1977 | 34(309) |
| 27-May-2012 |  Stephen Phillips | Crewe Alexandra | England | 06-May-1978 | 34(22) |
| 27-May-2012 |  Steve Elliott | Cheltenham Town | England | 29-Oct-1978 | 33(211) |
| 16-May-2012 | Chris Barker | Southend United | England | 02-Mar-1980 | 32(75) |
| 17-May-2012 |  Kevin Nicholson | Torquay United | England | 02-Oct-1980 | 31(228) |
| 27-May-2012 | David Artell | Crewe Alexandra | Gibraltar | 22-Nov-1980 | 31(186) |
| 27-May-2012 | Alan Bennett | Cheltenham Town | Republic of Ireland | 04-Oct-1981 | 30(236) |
| 27-May-2012 | Ben Burgess | Cheltenham Town | Republic of Ireland | 09-Nov-1981 | 30(200) |
| 12-May-2012 | Mark Phillips | Southend United | England | 27-Jan-1982 | 30(106) |
| 17-May-2012 | Lee Mansell | Torquay United | England | 23-Sep-1982 | 29(237) |
| 27-May-2012 | Lee Bell | Crewe Alexandra | England | 26-Jan-1983 | 29(122) |
| 16-May-2012 | Peter Gilbert | Southend United | Wales | 31-Jul-1983 | 28(290) |
| 16-May-2012 | Freddy Eastwood | Southend United | Wales | 29-Oct-1983 | 28(200) |
| 13-May-2012 | Darryl Duffy | Cheltenham Town | Scotland | 16-Apr-1984 | 28(27) |
| 27-May-2012 | Jeff Goulding | Cheltenham Town | England | 13-May-1984 | 28(14) |
| 27-May-2012 | Kaid Mohamed | Cheltenham Town | Wales | 23-Jul-1984 | 27(308) |
| 16-May-2012 | Michael Timlin | Southend United | Republic of Ireland | 19-Mar-1985 | 27(58) |
| 27-May-2012 | Scott P Brown | Cheltenham Town | England | 26-Apr-1985 | 27(31) |
| 17-May-2012 | Taiwo Atieno | Torquay United | Kenya | 06-Aug-1985 | 26(285) |
| 17-May-2012 | Keith Lowe | Cheltenham Town | England | 13-Sep-1985 | 26(247) |
| 27-May-2012 | Russell Penn | Cheltenham Town | England | 08-Nov-1985 | 26(201) |
| 13-May-2012 | Brian Smikle | Cheltenham Town | England | 03-Nov-1985 | 26(192) |
| 17-May-2012 | Ryan Jarvis | Torquay United | England | 11-Jul-1986 | 25(311) |
| 27-May-2012 | Carl Martin | Crewe Alexandra | England | 24-Oct-1986 | 25(216) |
| 13-May-2012 | Rene Howe | Torquay United | England | 22-Oct-1986 | 25(204) |
| 17-May-2012 | Robert Olejnik | Torquay United | Austria | 26-Nov-1986 | 25(173) |
| 17-May-2012 | Danny Stevens | Torquay United | England | 26-Nov-1986 | 25(173) |
| 16-May-2012 | Sean Clohessy | Southend United | England | 12-Dec-1986 | 25(156) |
| 17-May-2012 | Brian Saah | Torquay United | England | 16-Dec-1986 | 25(153) |
| 17-May-2012 | Ian Morris | Torquay United | Republic of Ireland | 27-Feb-1987 | 25(80) |
| 16-May-2012 | Anthony Grant | Southend United | Jamaica | 04-Jun-1987 | 24(347) |
| 16-May-2012 | Bilel Mohsni | Southend United | Tunisia | 21-Jul-1987 | 24(300) |
| 27-May-2012 | Sido Jombati | Cheltenham Town | Portugal | 20-Aug-1987 | 24(281) |
| 16-May-2012 | Elliot Benyon | Southend United | England | 29-Aug-1987 | 24(261) |
| 27-May-2012 | Adam Dugdale | Crewe Alexandra | England | 13-Sep-1987 | 24(257) |
| 27-May-2012 | Luke Summerfield | Cheltenham Town | England | 06-Dec-1987 | 24(173) |
| 16-May-2012 | Ryan Hall | Southend United | England | 04-Jan-1988 | 24(133) |
| 27-May-2012 | Jermaine McGlashan | Cheltenham Town | England | 14-Apr-1988 | 24(43) |
| 16-May-2012 | Luke Prosser | Southend United | England | 28-May-1988 | 23(353) |
| 27-May-2012 | Byron Moore | Crewe Alexandra | England | 24-Aug-1988 | 23(276) |
| 17-May-2012 | Mark Ellis | Torquay United | England | 30-Sep-1988 | 23(229) |
| 16-May-2012 | Cameron Belford | Southend United | Wales | 16-Oct-1988 | 23(212) |
| 27-May-2012 | Luke Murphy | Crewe Alexandra | England | 21-Oct-1989 | 22(219) |
| 17-May-2012 | Damon Lathrope | Torquay United | England | 28-Oct-1989 | 22(202) |
| 13-May-2012 | Lathaniel Rowe-Turner | Torquay United | England | 12-Nov-1989 | 22(183) |
| 27-May-2012 | AJ Leitch-Smith | Crewe Alexandra | England | 06-Mar-1990 | 22(83) |
| 27-May-2012 | Ashley Westwood | Crewe Alexandra | England | 01-Apr-1990 | 22(57) |
| 17-May-2012 | Joe Oastler | Torquay United | England | 03-Jul-1990 | 21(319) |
| 17-May-2012 | Eunan O'Kane | Torquay United | Republic of Ireland | 10-Jul-1990 | 21(312) |
| 27-May-2012 | Matt Tootle | Crewe Alexandra | England | 11-Oct-1990 | 21(229) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).