| # | Players | Clubs | Nationality | GC | More |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tony Roberts | Dagenham & Redbridge | Wales | 70 | |
| 2 | John Danby | Chester City | England | 68 | |
| 3 | Glynn Garner | Shrewsbury Town | Wales | 60 | |
| 4 | Andy Warrington | Rotherham United | England | 58 | |
| 5 | Alan Marriott | Lincoln City | England | 56 | |
| 6 | Lee Harrison | Barnet | England | 55 | |
| 7 | Barry Roche | Chesterfield | Republic of Ireland | 55 | |
| 8 | Phil Barnes | Grimsby Town | England | 54 | |
| 9 | Carl Muggleton | Mansfield Town | England | 54 | |
| 10 | Conrad Logan | Stockport County | Republic of Ireland | 47 | |
| 11 | Ian Dunbavin | Accrington Stanley | England | 46 | |
| 12 | Jim Provett | Bury | England | 46 | |
| 13 | Wayne Brown | Hereford United | England | 43 | |
| 14 | Simon Brown | Brentford | England | 43 | |
| 15 | Kevin Pilkington | Notts County | England | 40 | |
| 16 | David Stockdale | Darlington | England | 40 | |
| 17 | Kenny Arthur | Accrington Stanley | Scotland | 39 | |
| 18 | Joe Lewis | Morecambe | England | 39 | |
| 19 | Jonny Brain | Macclesfield Town | England | 38 | |
| 20 | Tommy Lee | Macclesfield Town | England | 36 |
GC = Goals conceded