| MD | Players | Clubs | Nationality | DOB | A(D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Kevin Poole | Burton Albion | England | 21-Jul-1963 | 46(22) |
| 11-Aug-2009 | Paul Furlong | Barnet | England | 01-Oct-1968 | 40(314) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Tony Roberts | Dagenham & Redbridge | Wales | 04-Aug-1969 | 40(7) |
| 25-Aug-2009 |  Chris Powell | Leicester City | England | 08-Sep-1969 | 39(352) |
| 27-Jan-2010 |  Edwin van der Sar | Manchester United | Netherlands | 29-Oct-1970 | 39(91) |
| 22-Sep-2009 |  Dean Kiely | West Bromwich Albion | Republic of Ireland | 10-Oct-1970 | 38(348) |
| 28-Feb-2010 |  Brad Friedel | Aston Villa | United States | 18-May-1971 | 38(287) |
| 22-Sep-2009 |  Maik Taylor | Birmingham City | Northern Ireland | 04-Sep-1971 | 38(19) |
| 25-Aug-2009 |  Simon Royce | Gillingham | England | 09-Sep-1971 | 37(351) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Ian Bennett | Sheffield United | England | 10-Oct-1971 | 37(306) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Efetobore Sodje | Bury | Nigeria | 05-Feb-1972 | 37(188) |
| 26-Aug-2009 |  Mike Pollitt | Wigan Athletic | England | 29-Feb-1972 | 37(179) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Barry Hayles | Cheltenham Town | Jamaica | 17-Apr-1972 | 37(116) |
| 23-Sep-2009 |  Marcus Hahnemann | Wolverhampton Wanderers | United States | 15-Jun-1972 | 37(100) |
| 25-Aug-2009 |  Ian Goodison | Tranmere Rovers | Jamaica | 05-Aug-1972 | 37(20) |
| 25-Aug-2009 | Paul Dickov | Leicester City | Scotland | 01-Nov-1972 | 36(297) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Marcus Stewart | Exeter City | England | 07-Nov-1972 | 36(277) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Russell Hoult | Notts County | England | 22-Nov-1972 | 36(262) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Paul Gerrard | Stockport County | England | 22-Jan-1973 | 36(201) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Kevin Austin | Chesterfield | Trinidad and Tobago | 12-Feb-1973 | 36(180) |
| 11-Aug-2009 | Alex Russell | Exeter City | England | 17-Mar-1973 | 36(147) |
| 25-Aug-2009 |  Chris Perry | Southampton | England | 26-Apr-1973 | 36(121) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Paul Warne | Rotherham United | England | 08-May-1973 | 36(95) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Nathan Jones | Yeovil Town | Wales | 28-May-1973 | 36(75) |
| 26-Aug-2009 | Andrew Liddell | Rotherham United | Scotland | 28-Jun-1973 | 36(59) |
| 22-Sep-2009 | Kevin Phillips | Birmingham City | England | 25-Jul-1973 | 36(59) |
| 27-Jan-2010 | Ryan Giggs | Manchester United | Wales | 29-Nov-1973 | 36(59) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Willy Gueret | Milton Keynes Dons | France | 03-Aug-1973 | 36(8) |
| 25-Aug-2009 |  Danny Coyne | Middlesbrough | Wales | 27-Aug-1973 | 35(364) |
| 26-Aug-2009 |  Carlo Cudicini | Tottenham Hotspur | Italy | 06-Sep-1973 | 35(355) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Nicky Forster | Brighton & Hove Albion | England | 08-Sep-1973 | 35(338) |
| 11-Aug-2009 | Nick Colgan | Grimsby Town | Republic of Ireland | 19-Sep-1973 | 35(327) |
| 25-Aug-2009 |  Geoff Horsfield | Port Vale | England | 01-Nov-1973 | 35(298) |
| 19-Jan-2010 |  Silvinho | Manchester City | Brazil | 12-Apr-1974 | 35(283) |
| 26-Aug-2009 |  Graham Kavanagh | Carlisle United | Republic of Ireland | 02-Dec-1973 | 35(268) |
| 23-Sep-2009 |  Nick Barmby | Hull City | England | 11-Feb-1974 | 35(225) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Dougie Freedman | Southend United | Scotland | 21-Jan-1974 | 35(203) |
| 27-Oct-2009 |  Darren Moore | Barnsley | Jamaica | 22-Apr-1974 | 35(189) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Scott McGleish | Leyton Orient | England | 10-Feb-1974 | 35(183) |
| 25-Aug-2009 | Lee Carsley | Birmingham City | Republic of Ireland | 28-Feb-1974 | 35(179) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Radek Cerny | Queens Park Rangers | Czech Republic | 18-Feb-1974 | 35(175) |
| 11-Aug-2009 | Michael Simpson | Burton Albion | England | 28-Feb-1974 | 35(165) |
| 11-Aug-2009 | Paul Mullin | Accrington Stanley | England | 16-Mar-1974 | 35(149) |
| 01-Dec-2009 |  Hermann Hreidarsson | Portsmouth | Iceland | 11-Jul-1974 | 35(144) |
| 11-Aug-2009 |  Sean Gregan | Oldham Athletic | England | 29-Mar-1974 | 35(136) |
| 25-Aug-2009 | Tony Warner | Hull City | England | 11-May-1974 | 35(107) |
| 11-Aug-2009 | Scott Murray | Yeovil Town | Scotland | 26-May-1974 | 35(78) |
| 27-Jan-2010 | Paul Scholes | Manchester United | England | 16-Nov-1974 | 35(73) |
| 11-Aug-2009 | Michel Kuipers | Brighton & Hove Albion | Netherlands | 26-Jun-1974 | 35(47) |
| 28-Feb-2010 | Gary Neville | Manchester United | England | 18-Feb-1975 | 35(11) |
MD = Match date,
DOB = Date Of Birth,
A(D) = Age(Days).