| Yellow | Clubs | VS Club | Date | Sections | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Arsenal | Manchester City | 02-12-2009 | Quarter Finals | Match details |
| 5 | Port Vale | Scunthorpe United | 22-09-2009 | Third Round | Match details |
| 5 | Newcastle United | Peterborough United | 22-09-2009 | Third Round | Match details |
| 4 | Swansea City | Scunthorpe United | 25-08-2009 | Second Round | Match details |
| 4 | West Ham United | Millwall | 25-08-2009 | Second Round | Match details |
| 4 | Blackburn Rovers | Gillingham | 25-08-2009 | Second Round | Match details |
| 4 | Plymouth Argyle | Gillingham | 11-08-2009 | First Round | Match details |
| 3 | Portsmouth | Aston Villa | 01-12-2009 | Quarter Finals | Match details |
| 3 | Barnsley | Manchester United | 27-10-2009 | Fourth Round | Match details |
| 3 | Everton | Tottenham Hotspur | 27-10-2009 | Fourth Round | Match details |
